TrainingWeb:
Juggling Man   
Report on the Feasibility of an Online
Training Environment for Staff of the WIC Program
(Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children).

Author: Kathleen M. Lyons, MS, RD
FastNet Media, Boston, MA.

Submitted to The Massachusetts Department of Public Health,
WIC Program
April 30,1998


Contents   Executive Summary   Feedback   About the Author



Contents

Executive Summary

Scope and Conclusions

1. Goals and Objectives
2. Climate & Capabilities
3. TrainingWeb Model
4. Links to Learning
5. Resources

Appendices
A. References
B. Chart: Glossary of Terms
C. Acknowledgements

Back to First Page


Executive Summary

New Technologies for Learning

Public sector organizations are under constant pressure to increase worker productivity while reducing operating costs. Performance of many program tasks can be improved through timely and effective staff training and performance support systems. Traditional, instructor-led training is being augmented or supplanted by user-centric systems that employ a number of integrated, flexible learning approaches. Self-paced, technology-enabled learning is task driven, and is characterized by productivity tools that lead to measurable changes in staff competency and performance.

 

Management guru Peter Drucker characterizes public-sector organizations as:

" on the cutting edge of management techniques, particularly in developing and implementing strategy, responding to constituents, motivating and training workers, and exerting leadership".

 

The Massachusetts WIC Program has historically been innovative in the development of training and performance support solutions for staff at state and local levels. Formal training programs have been in place for over fifteen years, and in 1992, WIC embarked on a new venture, The Learning Center (TLC). The Learning Center responds to the ever-increasing need for staff to be proficient in technical and computer as well as traditional operations and nutrition skills.

The Learning Center, located in Framingham, Massachusetts, is WIC’s staff training and development facility, providing space for traditional classroom training, computer laboratory, library and media center. The Learning Center serves both new and experienced staff, and is designed according to principles of adult learning, emphasizing interactive and hands-on learning experiences.

 

In FY1994, Massachusetts WIC began development of a technology-based training instrument for newly-hired staff. "Welcome to WIC", in CD/ROM format, includes modules on Orientation to WIC, How to Use WIC Checks, The WIC Computer System, Nutrition Education and Counseling, The WIC Food Package, and Making Referrals. These interactive training tools are available to new staff at field sites from their first day on the job, and contribute to orientation and the early mastery of mission-critical skills.

 

The concept of learner-driven training has been extended in recent years by the advent of the Internet and World Wide Web. Public as well as private organizations have seen the value of presenting training and performance support material using this convenient, efficient new technology. The ability to create flexible, easily-modified material and distribute it cheaply and immediately has great appeal in the training realm.

 

This report outlines a preliminary study of the logistical, technical, and pedagogical feasibility of using the Internet to create an online training and performance support environment for Massachusetts WIC. As an adjunct training delivery mode, a TrainingWeb site on the World Wide Web will add value to the overall training and support function of the Program. The TrainingWeb will reinforce strategic goals and objectives of the WIC community, through enhanced access to WIC information, as well as greater opportunities for communication and collaboration.

The TrainingWeb project seeks to establish a virtual space where staff, administrators, advocates, vendors and providers may meet, exchange information, and build knowledge of the many complex facets of WIC.

In future phases of the project, using existing hardware, WIC can set up economical training courses for asynchronous distribution to staff throughout the state, and later to other states, sharing development costs and expertise with a wide community of learners.

 

TrainingWeb project deliverables:

- Feasibility Study report (this document)

- Web site design document, including graphical interface design

- Content design

- Online Prototype with basic links to subject areas

 

Scope:

The preliminary study includes:

Research into the feasibility of establishing an online presence for the WIC Learning Center

Conclusions reached based upon research, history and culture of the organization

A discussion of the existing climate and capabilities of the WIC Program that would impact a successful project

A recommended model, in narrative form, of a prototype website to be developed in state FY 1998

An outline of the resources (tools, personnel, funding) that would be required to execute a successful implementation

 

Issues not included in the study scope, but requiring consideration in later phases are: high-bandwidth elements such as sound, video, and animation; integration with future WIC Participant system, security, hardware and software standards, content selection protocols, general WIC operational uses of the Internet, and potential participant uses.

 

 

Back to First Page

Conclusions:

  1. There is inherent value in presenting WIC training information,courses and support material via the World Wide Web.
  2. An online learning architecture would serve several purposes:

    Information

    Education

    Training

    Communication

    Productivity

     

  3. A prototype website should be limited in scope and functionality.
  4. The model described in Chapter 3 of this report describes a product limited in scope and functionality, as a demonstration of a larger application that would expand in a controlled manner.

     

  5. A mid-scale site (under 1000 pages) is recommended for the first year of implementation.
  6. State and local staff can collaborate and set priorities on training content to be developed for the initial site.

     

  7. Commitment of resources, both labor and materials, to a web-based communication and training process will yield efficiencies and savings:

Timely Communication
The Learning Center can use its website as a central calendar,registration and information tool that will allow staff both to view schedules of upcoming events, and to complete registration forms and surveys online.

 

Document Management
For example, extensive use of templates will allow TLC instructors to create electronic learning modules with little or no programming experience.

 

Collaborative Capabilities
Content creation and delivery can be expedited through use of the Internet as the design medium for collaborative projects.

  1. Formal agreements of collaboration with Massachusetts public and academic institutions, as well as with other states, will leverage training knowledge and content development for Massachusetts WIC.

    Collaboration with institutions such as Massachusetts state colleges and universities, EFNEP, non-profit maternal and child health organizations, and others, will offer significant leverage to WIC in formulating content for a training website.

 

Goal:

The overall goal of this study is to determine the educational, technical, logistical and financial feasibility of establishing an online presence in which to design and deliver training to staff of the Massachusetts WIC Program.

Objectives:

1

Assess the technical climate and capabilities that now exist in local agencies, the WIC state office, and The Learning Center, that would enable successful integration of an online learning environment.

 

2.

Determine the educational, technical and logistical needs around training that are not being met by the existing WIC staff training program. Using results of the 1997 WIC Strategic Plan, consider ways that an online system could expedite existing processes for designing, modifying, and delivering mission-critical WIC Program information.

 

3.

Describe a model of an online environment that would have a high probability of success in meeting ongoing staff training needs. Employ literature searches, interviews with content experts, technical experts, and prospective users, and online study of comparable projects using multimedia technologies to facilitate learning.

 

4.

Delineate the development steps required to produce the remaining deliverables, including a timeline; propose development steps for a follow-on demonstration project.

 

5.

Outline the resources required for development of a Learning Center website: skills, personnel, hardware and software, other supplies, with a proposed budget for the follow-on demonstration project.

 

The TrainingWeb model addresses these needs:

Leverage and increase the value of TLC’s training programs

 

Develop "communities of interest" around topics of concern to learners.

 

Create a network to quickly inform and train a multicultural, geographically dispersed staff in implementation of new Program initiatives.

 

Provide a means for WIC staff to master the principles of online communication, research, and access to the broad knowledge base available on the Internet.

 

Assumptions underlying the TrainingWeb Model:

1. Ongoing learning is essential for organizational integrity.

Staff at all levels of the enterprise have a need to receive, quickly assimilate, and act on a volatile body of knowledge on a daily basis.

 

2. Traditional training models have strengths and limitations

Traditional, instructor-led staff training is valuable when it creates an environment conducive to adult learning.

Some limitations of this traditional model include:

Access issues

Lack of specificity

Information overload/Low retention

Lack of Follow-up

Inconsistent Learning

High dependence and support costs

Untimely Learning

 

3. Electronic training delivery has proven benefits.

Professionals engaged in corporate and government training programs, and in the development of performance support systems, have long recognized the value of electronic training delivery modes.

Return on Investment

Compared with traditional, instructor-led training, Interactive Multimedia Training can reduce training cost by fifty per cent

 

In trials, IMT has achieved an equal or higher-quality level of learning, delivered in forty to sixty per cent less time than instructor-led training

 

Data Quality
Time-sensitive documents that are currently distributed via paper only can be made available electronically and updated with minimal effort and expense.

 

Targeted Learning
Staff can access information and communicate at their current level of comprehension, and progress to a more in-depth level of knowledge.

 

"Just Enough, Just in Time"
Performance Support tools delivered online are accessible at the right moment.

 

Consistent Message
Consistency of message is achieved as all stakeholders are "reading from the same page".

 

Template Design
Training and communications templates will serve as replicable models that users will recognize and identify with particular topics.

 

Recruitment/Retention
As a recruitment/retention tool, integration of online resources will facilitate nutritionists' connection with peers and foster an environment of continuous learning.

 

 

4. Government and public-sector organizations are moving to the online environment.

State and federal government agencies, as well as non-profit organizations, are increasingly presenting mission-critical information on the World Wide Web.

 

 

5. Massachusetts WIC staff are familiar with computer-based reference, training and performance support tools.
Since conversion to an automated check-issuance and data reporting system in 1991, Massachusetts WIC has been in the forefront of technological innovation both statewide and nationally. WIC staff in Massachusetts have become largely knowledge workers, proficient in data entry and retrieval.

 

 

6. Requisite logistical and technical expertise is available
The U.S. Department of Agriculture, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Department of Public Health and Massachusetts WIC Program have all had experience in establishing and maintaining online presence with sophisticated access, security and functionality features. The development of a TrainingWeb would be supported by a team of subject matter experts, technical staff, trainers, administrators and end users.

 

7. Massachusetts WIC's prototype site will provide a model
Universal access to the World Wide Web will enable other WIC programs to emulate the model created by Massachusetts WIC. In addition, joint training design and development activities can be initiated by states with similar needs, distributing the design effort with benefit to all.

 

8. WIC's primary mission will be served
Training is inextricably linked to performance: transition problems for new Program initiatives, program changes and compliance issues are all dependent, to some extent, on training as a solution. The WIC TrainingWeb will exploit the Internet, with its high levels of manageability, flexibility and ease of use, to quickly inform and train staff on new and modified Program policies and strategies.

 

Back to First Page


Further information on the Massachusetts WIC Program can be found at:

FastNet Media Web Site      or    Massachusetts Department of Public Health


Chapter 3. Description of the TrainingWeb Model

This Chapter describes the proposed TLC Website model, including an overview of site content, description of technical requirements for the prototype design, and logistical considerations involved in site administration. Chapter 4 describes a phased approach to expansion of the site considering personnel, financial and other resources.

As mentioned in Chapter 1, the TLC Website serves not only as a point of access to Massachusetts WIC’s learning resources, but also as a learning tool itself. This site provides a means for WIC staff to master the principles of online communication, navigation and research, at low risk to Program operational integrity.

Site Content
In the forthcoming Content Design Document, site content will be delineated according to priorities established by WIC staff user groups. In general, the prototype model of the TLC Website will comprise these content areas:

Home Page
Introductory page with links.
The Home Page of the TLC site comprises a simple graphic image map with links to the four major site areas: The Office, The Library, Media Resource Center, and The Conference Room. Top and/or bottom banners are displayed on each page of the site, with navigational links to the Massachusetts WIC Program, Department of Public Health, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and USDA Food and Consumer Services. A sidebar offers consistent access to the major areas on all site pages.

The Office
This area of the site is the ‘Housekeeping’ sector, where Learning Center announcements, calendar of events, and course registration information are located. Some branches from the main page are:

What’s New:
Features upcoming events, awards, or other relevant ‘news’.

TLC Mission:
Outline of TLC’s goals and objectives, explanation of the learning partnership among staff, local agency supervisors, and TLC.

Frequently-Asked Questions (FAQ)

About TLC: Catalogs questions about training programs
About WIC: Q & A about basic WIC operations, culled from existing paper-based documents

Calendar of Events:
Calendars of TLC and WIC events become dynamic documents, e.g., added-on events can be flagged with a ‘New’ sign, etc. Changes in Calendar dates, submission deadlines, and other important dates can be highlighted, with an EMail message sent to all sites pointing to the critical change. Bulletin Boards, "Public Folders", and password-protected areas can be added for limited access to some calendars. A job-specific Course Catalog can be linked to the calendar for New Staff Training, and include outlines and syllabi.

Registration forms:
This section of the Office contains forms for each pending training event, which can be electronically submitted by local agencies, or printed, copied and mailed or faxed to TLC.

TLC Staff Profiles:
Photos and profiles of TLC staff give learners advance information before attending training.

Contact TLC:
Link for EMail to TLC Administration and Webmaster.


The Library
This area of the site functions as ‘Learning Central’, a repository for training documents including Learning Modules & Lesson Plans, session notes and ‘Homework’ documents for access by learners.

Document Storeroom
This will serve as a distribution area for the indexing and downloading of files containing up-to-date versions of template files for common applications, and documents in ‘Read Only’ form, i.e. Acrobat PDF (Portable Document Format) files. Using currently-owned hardware and software, TLC staff can scan ‘snapshots’ of documents and make them available for download to local offices. Interacting with this area will give staff practice in accessing, downloading, storing and retrieving information electronically, and will assist in later efforts in document sharing, online drafting and publishing of other WIC documents.

Catalog of Circulating Materials
The Library also contains a Searchable Index of video holdings and other materials at the TLC Library. In Year 2, local agencies will be able to borrow materials using electronic forms. Some of the items in the Virtual Catalog:

  • Support materials : Index of training materials produced by WIC; handouts, brochures, templates etc.
  • Archives of TLC Case Studies, by Topic
  • Photo Gallery - photos of TLC and local community events
  • Links to National Agricultural Library holdings

Media Resource Center
Interactive Multimedia Training modules
Online, interactive lessons addressing skill and knowledge needs of WIC staff reside here.

  • Year 1: Interactive Triage Tool - Pregnancy Risk Factors
  • Year 2: Internet-enabled version of "Welcome to WIC"
  • Additional new modules as indicated
  • "Welcome to WIC": description of existing IMT modules, CD/ROM description with address to obtain copies.
  • Online courses - links to other sites
  • TLC and Massachusetts WIC Project Plans
  • Link to TLC Course Announcements and Syllabi
  • Links to relevant training sites on the WWW

Web-Based Training In Year 2, a Web-Based Training Initiative will enable the Program to create and disseminate learning experiences to Massachusetts and other states, using one of the major Web-Based Training applications currently on the market. WBT allows an instructor to post learning modules, make assignments, communicate individually with students, and receive completed work, all in an asynchronous, EMail-based process.

The Conference Room

Live Discussion Forums (using Internet Relay Chat):
IRC (Internet Relay Chat) software, available free on the Internet, allows a group of people to communicate in real time, discussing topics of interest in a ‘Forum’ format, with a moderator. This area enables WIC staff to ‘meet’ at scheduled times to discuss important and timely issues, moderated by TLC, state or local staff. The area comprises an index of Forum topics, Schedule of Live Forum sessions, Instructions for joining or initiating a Forum, and an Archive of Forum session transcripts. A monthly "Talking With…." forum could feature guest experts and/or WIC staff from other states.

Listservs
These ‘asynchronous’ Mailing Lists, are organized by topic, and use EMail to distribute ‘postings’, or comments by members of the list. ‘Threads’ of discussion are recorded for all members to read, and include initial postings as well as all responses received. This is useful when an IRC channel is not practical, or when the topic warrants a longer comment period, such as when formal comment is being sought on a pending policy issue. Included in this area is a list of available listservs, ‘List etiquette/How to Join’ information, and links to other listservs of interest. Year 2-3: Distance Learning/Videoconferencing capability When staff are comfortable with communicating electronically, a pilot course can be considered, using Internet videoconferencing software and hardware. Courses are presented in real time by TLC staff, with learners connected by desktop videoconferencing, using the Internet, available audio systems and small mini-cams.

Technical specifications:
For the TLC Website to progress beyond the prototype stage, several technical issues will need to be addressed. These include, but are not limited to:

  1. Compliance with State and DPH norms for online products
  2. Maintenance of IT systems
  3. Capabilities of the Website on the server end:

    -Establishment of a virtual server, leased from a company, or
        purchase of a dedicated server
    -Server capacity
    -Webmastering services - functions able to be performed by staff
    -Mailto: Ability to handle Email and attachments
    -Mailing list/listserv ability - maintenance of files, user support
    -Ability to handle forms, that is, user fills out form and EMails to TLC
    -Database design compatible with existing systems
    -Security/ID considerations, file encryption
    Functional: new learning modules
    Capabilities for: testing,scoring,user tracking,(profile, bookmarking,other logistics),site map, logistics training : "How to use this site".

  4. Plug-ins: software required by users at remote sites:

    -Adobe Acrobat Reader
    -WinZip
    -EMail clients
    -Newsgroup software
    -FTP client
    -Virus check software
    -IRC client software
  5. Logistics/ Webmastering
    Design Conventions, Look and Feel, Navigation of the Site:
    As part of the design process, a graphical ‘look and feel’ will be formulated, to establish a unified theme for the site. Variations on currently-available WIC clipart, logos, and color scheme will lend continuity to the pages, and identify the site as a product of Massachusetts WIC. In the top or bottom banner, small logos of the Seal of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and DPH can be located, as pointers to their state websites.

  6. Site Map
    Site design will include a site map, a page that provides an overview of the entire website, including all content areas and links to federal, state, and other WIC sites.

This model of a Website for The Learning Center is a preliminary design idea. It is expected that further development and clarification of the model will take place over time, particularly in the context of a demonstration project, but also as the result of continuing discussion among WIC constituencies. The overall goal, again, is to design a distinctive web presence for The Learning Center, and create a dynamic collaborative meeting and work space for all WIC staff.



Return to Contents Page

The TrainingWeb Feasibility Study: Feedback/Comments

Your comments, questions and suggestions regarding this report are welcome.
Contact FastNet Media with questions, or to obtain a copy of the full Feasibility Study Report.

Back to First Page

The TrainingWeb Feasibility Study: About the Author

Kathleen Lyons, MS,RD, is President of FastNet Media, Ltd., a training, consulting and development firm serving business and the helping professions. She has extensive experience in the Maternal and Child Health field, both as a nutritionist caring for high-risk maternity and neonatal patients, and as Director of an urban WIC Program in Boston. FastNet Media was founded in 1994 to design and produce training programs using interactive multimedia and traditional training tools.

Back to First Page

WebWork by FastNet Media
Copyright © 1998, Commonwealth of Massachusetts
No part of this document may be copied or distributed without the express permission of the owner.
For more information, contact FastNet Media